How Do You Know If Leadership Is Effective?

If you haven't defined what a good job looks like for leaders, how can you possibly know?

A leader delivers exceptional business results.

Their team is miserable.

Another leader has a team that absolutely adores them.

But they consistently miss their targets.

And another gets great results, has an engaged team, but hasn't developed a single person who could step into their role.

See the dilemma?

Which one is an effective leader?

And what are we using to make that decision?

I've been noodling on this quite a bit lately.

And I keep coming back to three things.

Results. Experience. Capacity.

  • What are leaders accomplishing?

  • What's it like to be led by them?

  • And are things getting better because of their leadership?

Three pretty straightforward questions.

But answering them requires us to do something we often overlook.

Define what a good job actually looks like.


What Does a Good Job Look Like for Leaders?

Here's something that makes me a little crazy.

We expect leaders to be effective without always getting clear about what effectiveness actually means.

We want them to deliver results. Build great teams. Develop people. Create healthy cultures. Navigate change. Solve problems.

Okay.

But what does success look like?

What specifically are they accountable for accomplishing? By when? How will we measure progress? How will we know when they've succeeded?

And have we made sure they're set up to succeed?

Because asking someone to be accountable for expectations that haven't been clearly defined and mutually understood is a pretty lousy strategy.

I'm a big fan of Ken Blanchard's version of SMART goals.

S — Specific
M — Motivating
A — Attainable
R — Relevant
T — Trackable

The S and T need to be written down somewhere.

Hopefully in a position agreement.

What does a good job look like? What needs to be accomplished? By when? How will we track progress and measure success?

The R, A, and M need a conversation.

Not a one-way communication where someone tells a leader what they're expected to do.

An actual dialogue.

Are the goals relevant? Are they attainable? Are they motivating?

What kind of support and direction does the leader need to be successful?

There's a big difference between telling someone what you expect and creating genuine alignment.

And if we want leaders to be effective, we need that alignment.

Across all three dimensions.


Results: What Are Leaders Accomplishing?

Let's start with the obvious one.

What quantifiable results are leaders accountable for delivering?

Revenue. Profitability. Budgets. Productivity. Quality. Safety. Customer satisfaction. Employee retention. Project milestones.

The specifics depend on the role.

A frontline supervisor has different accountabilities than a vice president of operations. And a CEO has different accountabilities than either of them.

But every leadership role exists to make a meaningful contribution to organizational success.

So, what does that contribution look like?

And how will we know whether it's happening?

Hopefully, you've got specific, trackable goals that make those expectations clear.

Not just a list of responsibilities.

Actual outcomes.

Because being busy isn't the same as being effective.

And checking all the boxes on a job description doesn't necessarily mean someone is delivering the results their role exists to produce.


Experience: What's It Like to Be Led by This Person?

Here's where things get interesting.

A leader might be delivering impressive business results.

But what's happening to the people they're leading?

Are people thriving?

Or are they exhausted, disengaged, afraid to speak up, and counting the days until they can leave?

Because results alone don't tell us whether leadership is effective.

The experience leaders create matters, too.

And we can measure it.

Employee feedback. Engagement surveys. Stay interviews. Exit interviews. Listening sessions. One-on-one conversations.

We can also learn a lot by paying attention to how people behave around a leader.

Do people speak openly? Ask questions? Share ideas? Raise concerns? Admit mistakes?

Or do they get quiet? Withhold information? Avoid difficult conversations? Tell the leader what they think they want to hear?

Those behaviors give us something to get curious about.

Not necessarily conclusions to jump to. But information worth exploring.

And here's another question.

Are people experiencing the culture your organization says it wants to create?

If your organization says it values trust, respect, accountability, and psychological safety, are people actually experiencing those things?

Or is there a big old gap between what you say matters and what happens day in and day out?

Because that gap matters.

And leaders play a pretty significant role in creating or closing it.


Capacity: Are Things Better Because of This Leader?

This might be my favorite one.

And one I think we overlook far too often.

Are things getting better because of this leader?

People? Processes? Systems? Relationships?

Is the team more capable today than it was six months ago? A year ago?

Are people growing? Are processes improving? Are relationships getting stronger? Are systems working better?

Is the leader building a team that can succeed without them having to be involved in everything?

Or have they made themselves indispensable?

Because those are two very different things.

Think about a leader who consistently hits their numbers.

They're the go-to person. They solve every problem. Make every decision. Have their hands in everything.

From the outside, they might look like a superstar.

But what happens when they leave?

What have they actually built?

Have they developed people who can step up? Improved the way work gets done? Strengthened the systems that support success?

Or does everything fall apart without them?

Effective leadership isn't just about delivering today's results. It's also about building the capacity for tomorrow's.

And yes, we can measure this, too.

Look at the data. Talk to people.

What's working better than it was before?

What can people do today that they couldn't do a year ago?

What has improved because of this leader's efforts?

And what's still unnecessarily difficult?

Those answers tell us something important.


We Need All Three

Here's why I think Results, Experience, and Capacity belong together.

A leader can deliver great results while leaving a trail of exhausted, disengaged people behind them.

A leader can create a wonderful experience for their team while consistently missing important business outcomes.

And a leader can achieve today's goals while slowly undermining the organization's ability to succeed tomorrow.

None of those sound particularly effective to me.

  • Results.

  • Experience.

  • Capacity.

We need all three.

And we need to get specific about what success looks like in each area.

Not vague aspirations.

Not a laundry list of leadership competencies.

Actual outcomes that reflect what each leadership role exists to accomplish.

And meaningful ways to track progress and measure success.

Otherwise, what exactly are we evaluating?


Here's a Little Something for You to Noodle On...

Think about how your organization defines and measures leadership effectiveness.

Results. Do leaders have clear, specific, trackable goals for the outcomes they're accountable for delivering?

Experience. Have you defined the experiences leaders are expected to create? And are you gathering feedback about what people are actually experiencing?

Capacity. Are leaders accountable for making people, processes, systems, and relationships better? And do you have a way to know whether that's happening?

And here's another one.

Have leaders actually had meaningful conversations about whether their goals are relevant, attainable, and motivating?

Or have we simply handed them a set of expectations and hoped for the best?

Finally, what are you doing with what you're learning?

Are you using that information to help leaders succeed?

Or just to evaluate their performance?

Because there's a difference.

And I think it's a pretty important one.

If we want leaders to be effective, we need to be intentional about defining what effectiveness looks like, measuring what matters, and creating the conditions for their success.

Not just expecting them to figure it out.

Leadership is too important to leave to chance.

Next
Next

Sitting in the Fire As a Leader (P2)